2006 |
| Zach Bond |
Arkansas Tech University |
| Blane Boss |
Northwestern State University |
| Steve Carter |
Lindenwood University |
| Trey Keene |
University of Northern Colorado |
| Adam Minter |
University of Northern Kentucky |
| Robinson Reyes |
Lindenwood University |
| Kyle Smith |
Bellarmine University |
| Carlos Suarez |
Lindenwood University |
| Zach Weiss |
Arkansas Tech University |
2005 |
| Justin Basinger |
William Woods University |
| Mike Franz |
Truman State University |
| Chris Danks |
Lindenwood University |
| Chris Gillgertsen |
University of West Alabama |
| Will Lawrence |
Murray State University |
| Greg Rodgers |
St. Louis University |
2004 |
| Mike Buda |
Western Carolina University |
| Randy Beilsmith |
Truman State University |
| James Guilliams |
University of West Alabama |
| Matt Rose |
University of Missouri - St. Louis |
| Sean Turner |
Culver Stockton College |
| Brooks Winner |
Lindenwood University |
2003 |
| Tom Becks |
Southern Illinois University-Edwardsville |
| Brett Bognar |
Northwest Missouri State |
| Chris Harden |
Lindenwood University |
| Mike Kraatz |
Southeast Missouri State University |
| Matt Mammen |
Lindenwood University /Arizona Diamondacks |
| Mike Mitchell |
Oakland A’s |
2002 |
| Matt Bennett |
Brockton Sox |
| John Bridges |
St. Louis University |
| Dane Carver |
Missouri Southern State University |
| Mark Catanzaro |
Missouri Southern State University |
| Dylan Ebert |
Missouri Southern State University |
| Kevin Sahrman |
University of Missouri - St. Louis |
2001 |
| Patrick Clooney |
William Woods University |
| Mark Craig |
Missouri Western State University |
| Brett Hendrick |
Harding University |
| Chris Maglich |
Northwest Missouri State |
| Stave Maher |
Lincoln University |
| Adam Murphy |
Mesa State University |
| Jim Reiter |
University of Missouri - St. Louis |
2000 |
| Joe Curtis |
University of Missouri - St. Louis |
| Adam Hayes |
Westminster College |
| B.J. Volz |
William Woods University |
| Keith Wallace |
University of Missouri - St. Louis |
1999 |
| Brian Beckmann |
University of Arkansas - Little Rock |
| Mike Scott |
Indiana State University |
| Kevin Meyer |
University of Missouri - St. Louis |
| Dan Poder |
William Jewel College |
| Bob Kern |
William Jewel College |
| Ryan Oetting |
Central Methodist University |
| Lance Wilson |
University of Missouri -- St. Louis |
